Here is a Journal Activity for you to complete that will require you to apply what you've just learned. Read the following passage on comparing points of view.
Next, answer the questions in the Thinking Skills section. Your Journal answers should be constructed using a word processing program. Label each Journal entry with the appropriate title, Journal Activity 3, and number each of your answers to correspond with the question.
Analyzing Data
Psychologists use field observations, laboratory experiments, and other methods to gather data relevant to their research questions. When sufficient data have been collected, the researchers analyze the data in order to make inferences about the research topic. The focus of data analysis is the identification of relationships between the various elements of the data. Researchers look for the following types of relationships.
The relationship of necessary condition.
A necessary condition is a condition without which a certain event or effect cannot occur. For example, for a procedural memory of a skill to occur, you must first learn the skill. You may not always remember a skill you have learned, but you can never remember it if you have not learned it. There are four possible relationships (R) between a necessary condition (A) and a certain effect (B).
R.1. If A occurs, then B may or may not occur.
R.2. If A does not occur, then B cannot occur.
R.3. If A occurs, then B must have occurred.
R.4. If A does not occur, then B may or may not have occurred.
The relationship of sufficient condition.
A sufficient condition is a condition that can produce a certain effect. The same effect, however, can be produced by other conditions. For example, brain injury can cause amnesia, but amnesia can also be caused by other conditions. There are four possible relationships between a sufficient condition C and a certain effect D.
R.1. If C occurs, then D occurs.
R.2. If C does not occur, then D may or may not occur.
R.3. If D occurs, then C may or may not have occurred.
R.4. If D does not occur, then C did not occur.
The relationship of necessary and sufficient condition.
If all necessary and sufficient conditions EF occur, then a certain effect G will always occur. If these conditions do not occur, then the effect will not occur. For example, to create memory of an incident, the brain must encode information. Without encoding, there will be no memory of the event. The following are true.
R.1. If EF occurs, then G will occur.
R.2. If EF does not occur, then G will not occur.
R.3. If G occurs, then EF has occurred.
R.4. If G does not occur, then EF has not occurred.
Thinking Skills:
Refer to the information about relationships to answer the following questions regarding analysis.
1. True or false? If data shows that saying a number over and over is a
necessary and sufficient condition for committing the number to
memory, then people who want to memorize a phone number must
repeat it several times.
2. A research study looking for early signs of Alzheimer's disease studied
the brains of 14 deceased nuns and examined the autobiographies of
the nuns, which were written early in their lives. Of the 5 nuns
diagnosed with Alzheimer's, all showed low-idea density in their writing, which means they included very little descriptive information in their
writing. The writing of the nuns without Alzheimer's did not show this
characteristic. The researcher's believed that low-density writing might
be a predictor for the development of Alzheimer's. Using A for
Alzheimer's and LDW for low-density writing, write a statement that
describes the relationship between Alzheimer's disease and low-density writing demonstrated by this study.
Is the relationship one of necessary condition, sufficient condition, or
necessary and sufficient condition?
Do you think this study is sufficient to come to that conclusion? Why or
why not?
3. Suppose experimental data showed that memory reliability has been
increased by 12 percent in people taking medication X and also has
been increased in people who have had training in using mnemonic
devices. Using DX for taking the drug and IM for result of improved
memory, write a statement that best describes the relationship.
4. Todd ate two bowls of popcorn while studying for his psychology test.
The next day he got an A on the test. Can he conclude that eating lots
of popcorn is a necessary condition for memorizing psychology
information? Why or why not?
5. Depict a scenario describing each of the three relationships with their
required conditions as discussed earlier in the Analyzing Data section of this Journal Activity.